Thoughts on Huniepop and Dating Sims
A few months ago, a developer that was interested in starting a new project asked me for some background on dating sims. Back then, I answered that dating sims were pretty much a relic of the 90’s , and that high profile games like Tokimeki Memorial aren’t nearly as common now.
That is not to say that eroge and galge are no longer popular – the market for such games is probably larger now than ever before. To clarify, what distinguishes dating sims from the plethora of other games where the protagonist develops romantic relationships with a virtual harem is the focus on dating as the primary game mechanic. Games that are well known to the English speaking community like Kanon of Megatokyo fame, or Fate/Stay Night are often put in the dating sim category but the term “visual novel” is more appropriate, emphasizing that these games focus on telling a narrative rather than providing an interactive game.
It doesn’t surprise me that less than half a year after I explained that dating sims aren’t really a thing anymore, that Huniepop exploded into mainstream recognition, a game created surprisingly by Western developers targeting an English speaking audience. I’m aware that some of the sudden popularity was created by some manufactured controversies about the game’s content, but that’s not really what got me interested in the game.
What caught my interest was this video that got passed around a lot more after the Steam release:
It’s not exactly quality writing, and the material doesn’t really showcase enough to judge the voice acting. It was, however, funny in the sense that unrefined verbal brawls between two barbarians can be funny (what makes these kinds of things funny is probably a good candidate for my pretentious ramblings about fiction). At the time, I wasn’t interested in the game itself (I understood it to be a Bejeweled clone, a game I don’t really have much regards for), so I decided to watch some Let’s Plays in order to find out more about these characters without having to trudge through the gameplay. To make a long story short, I bought the game because the player on youtube was so inefficient that it actually bothered me. Huniepop is pretty much kusoge – the visuals, voice acting, and gameplay feel amateurish—and I bought it because the game looked fun.
To make it clear from the start, if you were ever interested in Huniepop because of the outrageous writing samples, you will probably be disappointed. The videos you saw on Youtube are almost all of the dialogue in the game. The game is two parts resource management, one part Bejeweled, and one very small part dialogue reading. I’m pretty obsessive about solving utility maximization problems, and I’m a sucker for really bad harem anime, so the enjoyment I got out of the game was worth the indignity of broadcasting that I was playing Huniepop to all my Steam friends for a few days.
The Econ 101 Problem:
You have to successfully date girls (presumably all of them, but of course it’s okay to stop after you finish your favorite one), while managing 3 resources: Munie (money), Hunie (experience points), and time. This is the standard formula for a dating sim, and Huniepop doesn’t do anything different here.
The basic unit of time in Huniepop is the day. Each day can be further broken up into 4 parts, Morning, Afternoon, Evening, and Night. There are two things that make the day significant as a measure of time. The first is that you can only date any particular girl once in a given day, regardless of how many smaller parts of the day you choose to spend with that girl. The second is that the item shop restocks with random items at Morning of each day.
Each individual part of the day refills your girl’s energy meter, so that you can talk to the girl more. Talking to the girl is similar to other dating sims in that you learn more details about the girl, and will get periodically quizzed. There was a bit of nostalgia factor for me because you don’t really need to take notes with pencil and paper anymore while playing computer games.
The main difference between Huniepop and other dating sims is that these interactions don’t directly affect your relationship with the girl. Answering questions correctly and learning new things about the girl adds to your total Hunie savings, and there is no mood or affection meter to worry about managing. In fact, the only thing that affects your relationship is the number of successful dates that you have with that girl, or in other words, the number of times you win the Bejeweled mini-game with that girl. Dates are also the only to gain Munie, and you always receive Munie based on your score in the mini-game whether you win or lose.
Munie is used to buy items, which can be food, alcohol, or gifts. Even this simplication of the item purchase mechanic makes it seem more complicated than it really is, because every item you buy has essentially one purpose – to gain more Hunie. Food refills your energy bar, which allows you to talk more with the girl, which gives you more Hunie. Alcohol fills the intoxication meter, which is a bar that resets every time period, and being more drunk increases the amount of Hunie you get for talking with the girl. Gifts either give you a flat amount of Hunie, or increase the amount of Hunie you get from talking with the girl, both effects giving you more Hunie. They also unlock new hairstyles for the girls, but by the time you would be working on unlocking these things, time rather than Munie is the limiting resource because you cannot buy what is not stocked in the shop (not all items are available to purchase on any given day). Using Munie efficiently is just figuring out which items will give you the most Hunie.
Hunie is used to level up your character’s stats, making it easier to win the dating mini-game. The actual mini-game itself I don’t think is very interesting – the main thing to know about it for purposes of the utility maximization problem is that the number of dates you can finish is directly related to the level of your stats.
Using these three resources, you want to maximize the number of successful dates, and I leave it as an exercise to the player to determine the solution.
As a puzzle to be solved, the time management aspect of the game is pretty addicting. You get plenty of positive feedback for doing things right… for a while. One major flaw is that time is an unlimited resource (unless you’re constrained by real life time outside of the game). Other games have special days like Valentine’s Day, birthdays, or graduation to force the player to use time wisely or else lose out on events and goals. There is no such constraint in Huniepop, so you can actually just grind time into Munie/Hunie until you are so strong that you can’t fail dates, bypassing the time management aspect of the game altogether.
This means that there is no loss condition for the game, and you will eventually be able to obtain all of the content in the game given enough time. It also means that the game is kind of trivial if played without any self-imposed rules or goals. If your only goal in the game was to collect all the panties, this is great. If what you wanted was an interesting puzzle, this makes for a potentially dull experience. Some people are able to run a race by themselves and have fun (speedrunners for example), but other problem solvers do require help from the game to make interesting problems for them rather than throwing them in the metaphorical sandbox. Because time is an infinite resource that can be converted into Hunie and Munie, you effectively have infinite amounts of Hunie and Munie to spend. This makes the game a trivial exercise of throwing time at the problem.
But suppose you do try to keep yourself honest and try to do your best to progress at a reasonable pace without grinding. There is still a game balance problem that also makes the game trivial. While Hunie is meant to be the primary resource for progressing through dates, the rate that you can gain Hunie far exceeds the rate that the difficulty of the puzzles increases. In other words, you start getting much more Hunie than you need to beat the puzzles.
This problem can be ameliorated by increasing the difficulty level of the game, but even playing at the highest setting, I found that the final meaningful date puzzle could usually be solved with only 3 or 4 levels of the correct stat. Getting enough Hunie to get that number of stats is trivial, especially when you are working on your third girl or later. Changing the difficulty level only delays the point where you don’t need more Hunie to progress.
The worst part of this is that you will probably max all your stats long before you have finished all the objectives, and there is no game related reason to get more Hunie. This is like playing a 40 hour RPG and reaching level 99 ten hours into the game, still required to fight all the random battles. The end game of Huniepop is just grinding dates for the sake of increasing the affection meters, mostly ignoring the Hunie/Munie aspect of the game. I was maxed out on stats for most of the game and ran out of things to spend Hunie on, and I could never really spend all my Munie either because I had to wait for the right items to appear in the shop. It is reminiscent of the endgame in the Civilization games, where you are so far ahead of the AI that you’re just going through the motions of reaching the win condition without making any meaningful decisions, often times just hitting the next turn button immediately. If you play Huniepop as a strategy game, you should know that the point where you run out of meaningful decisions probably comes around a quarter into the game. This can be torturing if you actually want to collect all the content.
For me, the breaking point where I could no longer stand the meaningless grind came right after I collected the last CG, and nothing can convince me to go for a 100% clear. That is still most of the game, and about as far as all but the most hardcore completionists will get. There were enough meaningful choices to make in the early/mid game balancing time, Munie, and Hunie to pull me to the point that I felt that I might as well finish the rest of the game once it stopped being difficult. Huniepop works because it has that addicting “One more turn” (One more panty?) feel to it that games like Civilization and Persona have, and at the price the game sells for on Steam, hardcore strategy gamers shouldn’t have a problem justifying the purchase for one playthrough. That is of course as long as you aren’t offended by sexuality.
My initial impression of the game while playing it was that it suffered from an identity crisis. There isn’t enough interaction with the girls to really impress dating sim/visual novel fans (making interactions with the girls actually affect the relationship would have helped), while I’m not so sure that the Bejeweled playing audience is really looking for all the management involved in a dating sim. The real winners are those that just like figuring out mechanics and those that like collecting CG’s, as there is plenty to work with and find. If the primary goal of the developers was to just make a game with fun gameplay without worrying about the romance or puzzle aspect, they should be pretty happy with what they’ve done.
Thoughts on the Humor in Kanojo ga Flag wo Oraretara
Kanojo ga Flag wo Oraretara is one of those shows where the punchline of every gag is obvious the moment the gag starts. There’s no point in knocking it for being predictable, because things don’t have to be different for us to like them. In fact, this show thrives on predictability, and is a good example of why it’s nice to get what you see coming sometimes.
I wrote about this a few years ago when I was thinking about what made the humor in Seitokai Yakuindomo work – when executed correctly, a predictable punchline creates tension rather than killing it. As the audience, we have more information than the characters in the story, and start preparing ourselves for events that have yet to happen. You’ve probably noticed that many stories are only possible because the characters involved are idiots completely oblivious to the situation at hand and any possible solutions. Souta’s gimmick is that he actually isn’t oblivious to what’s going to happen. Every time some sort of dramatic event is about to happen, he sees a “flag” over the head of the person involved. This is where the show is self aware:
- Flags are binary states in games, and are a staple of the bishoujo game genre. Don’t think about this too much, but flags are super-generalized descriptors of relationships in a genre that is driven by stereotypes.
- The gags in this show are predictable because of how well the characters conform to the stereotypes that we assign to them.
- By explicitly revealing that the flag exists, you have to be completely clueless to realize how obvious everything up until this point was supposed to be. I’ll give the writer the benefit of the doubt and assume this is all on purpose.
Souta’s power to see the flag in a way, lets him in on the joke. If this were a tragedy, he would be aware of the hopelessness of the situation he is in. Oh wait, his situation is hopeless. Being stuck between the Yandere flag and breaking it to trigger the Romantic Conquest flag with no middle ground is pretty tragic, and this being a stereotypical harem show, he’ll probably end up breaking a lot more Romance flags.
In practice, while jokes often end with the actual action, the real impact of jokes in Kanojo ga Flag wo Oraretara is before the action. The punchline is the explicit revelation of the absurd generalization assigned to the scenario. Now this in itself can be funny depending on your sense of humor, but the very nature of this joke leads to a second generalization. The flag necessarily creates the alternative reality that Souta must choose from upon being revealed. To break or not to break the flag is in itself a comedic scenario in itself, and how Souta decides to act from there is the joke playing itself out. Call it a one-two punch. This formula is pretty good, and we’ll have to see how long it can continue delivering results, or if they scrap everything and change things up.
Other thoughts on the show:
Hanazawa Kana is still the most moe voice of this generation of voice actors, and is probably the best person they could have got for Megumu.
Kayano Ai reminds me a lot of Noto Mamiko, but is actually cast in a hyper-energetic role this time around. Akane’s voice was actually pretty aggravating to me in the beginning, but the character grew on me as more characters were added to the show. Her lines are kind of like a metronome, and help make sure that the impact of the gags gets delivered in a timely fashion.
Listen to the way characters speak – this is a show about generalizations, and it’s only fitting that everyone has a speech gimmick as an easy way to create more character diversity.
How Real Are Our Feelings?
One of the most important things to be able to do when thinking about complicated issues is to come up with good examples. Even if you can think of the most elegant abstract idea, if you can not think of an example for it, there is a good chance that there is something terribly wrong with it.
When talking to people about fiction, it is hard for me not to draw examples from anime, which has been such a large source of experiences over the past several years. However, it is obvious that a very large population would not get such references, limiting their usefulness as examples. Luckily for me, I have a broad range of sources to draw examples from, a good reason to indulge in a variety of hobbies, but something still feels lacking when you can’t really use that perfect example to make your point. Over the next few posts I will try to discuss an issue that has been of interest to me for a while, and perhaps to many others like myself, this time using my favorite examples.
Thinking about the music of G-Senjou no Maou
Over the past several months, I have had the pleasure of reading through Akabesoft2’s g-senjou no maou, and though I had finished it several weeks ago, I haven’t quite been able to get it out of my mind.
For an eroge, it is quite remarkable. Though I can hardly claim that my knowledge of the genre has much breadth, it does a lot of things “just right” that other games miss. The characters have familiar traits, but not overly so (with the exception of one very tsundere, but that is so well done that it is quite forgivable). The plot events are all familiar, but not overly so. As a life long lover of classical music, the music is also quite familiar, but not overly so.
How to play fighting games
It’s been a while since I’ve written something. I’ve been really busy for the most part, but part of the reason was the recent console release of Arcana Heart 3, which I just got a few weeks ago. Ironically though, it was my roommates who have been playing it the most, though I’ve been able to fit in a few hours here and there. When I was asked the question “How do you learn to play fighting games” I was surprised to find myself at a loss as to how to actually answer the question. I guess I’ll take some time then to organize what I believe to be the most important concepts to learn.
Looking deeper into fictional truths
In the last entry in what seems to be a monthly series looking at fiction, I wrote an awful lot about what is an almost trivial notion. That is, we can believe almost all things that happen explicitly in a work to be true. This could have been expressed in a single line, and no argument would be raised against it, but such truths are a very good example of the fundamental process behind creating fiction. That is, the author is constructing a universe that we call the “fictional world” with axioms that are known to be unconditionally true.
We ended considering a second kind of truth, one that we understand to be true because it is true in this world. Such truths compose the vast majority of the truths in the fictional world, and are perhaps the most important kinds.
2010, a year of quiet change
I often wonder when, if ever, I’ll completely grow out of my interest in anime. I don’t know how long I’ve been facing this feeling that most anime is really bad, shallow, and quite frankly a waste of time. Yet for every season where I feel like there’s nothing worth watching, I always find something that keeps my passion alive. I feel that 2010 was a process of redefining or perhaps rediscovering my interest in anime. There were several very pronounced, yet gentle trends.
Tantei Opera Milky Holmes
Over the past few years, I have noticed time and time again that among the shows that I find the most entertaining are those that I felt, at the same time, were incredibly stupid. Seitokai Yakuindomo was almost like this in that in general, I don’t find crude jokes funny at all. But I felt that there was a lot more going on to keep a thinking mind engaged.
Tantei Opera Milky Holmes seems to have almost no redeeming qualities, yet I still enjoyed it from start to finish. Let’s see what’s going on.
This is, for better or for worse, the heart and soul of Milky Holmes, and it seems J.C. Staff knew this.
On Conditional Statements and Demon Kings
Today saw the release of the English fan translation of G-Senjou no Maou, a game which I believe released 2 years ago or so. Not having kept up with this kind of thing for a while, I wasn’t even aware that another group had picked up the project after Asceai dropped it, or may have just forgotten it long ago. Regardless, it’s nice to see these kind of things succeeding, and is indicative of a much more established translation community than existed say, 5 years ago. Some minor spoilers ahead.
Clannad:Another Story, Kouko’s Diary
It’s been several months since I posted the first story I worked on. I’ve worked on another one of the stories in the mean time, but since a translation was already released for that, I never made the effort to finalize it. Maybe I’ll work on it though. It’s interesting looking back, and fixing up errors that now look strange, as my understanding of the lines just seems a lot better.
This time around, I tried to make for a more natural flow, rather than to preserve as much of the structure as possible. Maybe the vocabulary was a lot easier than the other works I’ve been working on, but the process just went by quicker. As for the story itself, typical Maeda fare, with a piercing ending (assuming you know the story), just what the fans expect. There are illustrations, that are quite nice, that I will probably try to get a hold of and insert in their relative locations, after I have access to the book again. Until then, enjoy.
